Sometimes you really do have to suffer for your art

I need to get outside or my brushwork gets too fussy.

Harkness Brook, oil on canvas with a splotch or two of snow, by Carol L. Douglas.

After I taught in Tallahassee in November, it took me a few weeks to acclimate myself to the temperature here in Maine. I expected that. I didnā€™t expect the same thing when I got home from Wyoming this week. It was warmer than usual there, and now the entire country has settled into the winter deep freeze.

Here in Maine, I usually spend a few hours a day outside. At dawn I hike up to the summit of Beech Hill. That gets the blood flowing for the day. At midday I go out again, either to the post office or on another off-road hike. I almost always get my 10,000 steps in without being aware that Iā€™m ā€˜exercisingā€™ or that itā€™s cold outside.

The wind-sculpted summit of Beech Hill.

But after Iā€™ve been on the road, Iā€™m always miserable the first few days back. ā€œMy everything hurts,ā€ I complained yesterday. Iā€™d been sitting behind the wheel of my new truck for a week, driving. At my age, I decondition far more quickly than I did at twenty.

My limit for sustained outdoor activity is 10Ā°F. Below that, itā€™s just too much work to stay warm. Luckily, I live right on the coast, where extreme cold is unusual. That ocean just beyond my backyard acts like a massive heatsink, cooling us in the summer and warming us in the winter.

Snow at Highter Elevations (Downdraft Snow) by Carol L. Douglas

But I can be fooled, as I was on Monday. The nominal temperature was in the teens, but as I rounded the summit, I was hit square in the face by a bitter wind. The wind often picks up as the sun rises, and this one was fierce. By the time we were back to the car, even my little dogā€”seemingly impervious to the coldā€”was acting chilled.

Still, the snow is beautiful, hanging on every evergreen branch. ā€œYou want to paint?ā€ I texted a few of my buddies. Only Ken DeWaard was foolish enough to agree. Dressed in my long underwear, mittens, neck gaiter, heavy jacket, and hardiest boots, I drove out to meet him. It was absolutely awful, but we both did sketches that we liked. Meanwhile, Eric Jacobsenwas painting near the top of Beech Hill, and he did a fine painting. Thereā€™s a lesson in that, I think. Sometimes you really do have to suffer for your art.

Meanwhile, itā€™s continued to snow, and the temperature continues to drop. Iā€™m looking out at the gloaming wondering if I want to go out to paint again today. It all depends on the light.

Why do we do this, when we each have nice, toasty-warm studios in which we can paint? One paints differently in the studio from in the field. I need regular days of painting from life so that I remember what life looks like when I paint from photos. Without that, my brushwork gets too fussy.

Postscript: my student Yvonne Bailey posted the above photo on Facebook. She had rearranged her furniture and swapped her dogsā€™ crates around. Creatures of habit, they both insisted on returning to where they thought they belonged. Thereā€™s a lesson in that for us as well: itā€™s easy for us humans to get overly attached to our ā€˜placesā€™. Habit is good, but it can become a rut.

What can you learn from a pumpkin?

The inner self emerges, despite our best efforts to keep it stuffed down.

Pumpkins by Maggie Daigle.

If the weather holds today, I’ll be painting with my pal Ken DeWaard. We donā€™t worry about painting the same subject. He doesnā€™t want to paint like me, andā€”because he wonā€™t let me copy off his paperā€”I donā€™t paint like him.

This week I assigned my Zoom classes to paint pumpkins. They’re in season, after all. After Iā€™d had that brilliant idea, I had to figure out something interesting to say on the subject. That was harder, but I eventually managed to marry pumpkins to a Big Idea in Painting.

Pumpkins by Mary Silver.

Color temperature is especially complicated on an orange (or blue) object, because theyā€™re at the outside edges of that useful artistic convention we call ā€œwarm and cool.ā€ If youā€™re managing the color of light by simply modulating all your colors with the same tinted white pigment, itā€™s no great problem. But if, like the Impressionists, youā€™re dialing around the color wheel to control the color of light, you run into a problem. Thereā€™s simply nowhere warmer than orange or cooler than ultramarine blue. That gave me a subject to talk about regarding pumpkins.

My students then proceeded to paint. And thatā€™s where the real learning startedā€¦ for me.

A leaning tower of pumpkins by Kathy Mannix (unfinished).

I wasnā€™t optimistic about the results. After all, how interesting could two dozen still-life paintings of pumpkins be? Itā€™s not as if the gourds were out in the field waiting to be gathered up, on plants, buried in leaves, or stacked in innovative ways. Shorn of context, they would be plopped on tables from Maine to Texas. I expected to harvest a crop of very similar paintings.

Instead, there was as much variety as there would have been if Iā€™d suggested self-portraits.

Pumpkins by Patricia Mabie.

Kathy Mannix stacked hers in a leaning tower. Samantha East added a large squash to break up the composition. Lorraine Nichols laid her gourds out on a textile printed with pumpkins; Maggie Daigle and Patricia Mabie played the stripes of their gourds against the stripes of textiles. Carrie Oā€™Brienā€™s pumpkins were reflected in the bowl of a silver spoon. Somehow, each painting was reflective of each artist, ā€œwarts and all,ā€ as Lori Galan joked about her own painting.

Pumpkins by Yvonne Bailey.

The arts are the voice of our inner self, but painting is uniquely self-expressive. Itā€™s influenced fairly equally by both our conscious and subconscious minds. Contrary to what you might think, our subconscious expression gets stronger the more we gain technical skill. When our process runs quietly in the background, thereā€™s space and time for our souls to start speaking.

For example, itā€™s impossible to mistake a Caravaggio for an Artemisia Gentileschi, even though both painted Biblical subjects, belong to the same general broad movement in art and underwent similar training. Itā€™s not just the lighting or drafting that immediately tell us which is which, either. The very personality of their work is different.

One very warty pumpkin by Lori Capron Galan (unfinished).

There are many reasons for a teacher to avoid trying to create mini-me painters in the studio, but itā€™s a pointless exercise anyway. The inner self emerges despite our best efforts to keep it stuffed down.

Iā€™m also remindedā€”againā€”that thereā€™s little point in trying to predict the outcome of my ideas. Sometimes Iā€™ll put something out that I think is dreck, and it catches the public imagination. Sometimes, Iā€™ll labor long and hard on something I think is brilliant, but nobody else much cares. Iā€™ve learned to just cast my bread upon the waters and let the results take care of themselves.