Is the night sky really dark blue?

Stapleton Park, 1877, John Atkinson Grimshaw, courtesy Christies

Laura Martinez-Bianco and I are convoy-camping to Sedona Plein Air. I’m excited, because the night sky is magical.

In my previous nocturne painting class, we discussed the colors artists have used to paint the night sky. Painters including John Atkinson Grimshaw and Frederic Remington used green to suggest moonlight. That observation prompted a discussion with my students about what we actually see in the night sky.

Painting student Jay Grate took the question further, researching the science of night-sky color and comparing it with his own observations. “People see the night sky as blue at twilight as it gets darker and assume it’s blue all night.” He noted that colored artificial lights warp color perception, and that historically, artificial lighting was very warm (candles or campfires). Seeing a dark sky in red light makes us perceive it as blue.

Moonlit Night on the Dnieper, 1882, Arkhip Kuindzhi, courtesy Russian Museum, Saint Petersburg

Cultural biases

We have a strong cultural bias towards seeing the night sky as blue. Photographers frequently adjust it that way. Especially with digital photography, the resulting image isn’t a true record of what the eye perceives.

Jay drew my attention to Color of the Night Sky by astrophotographer Roger N. Clark, who says the night sky contains a surprising variety of colors. Depending on atmospheric conditions, the light source and what we’re observing, those colors can include blue-gray, green, red, yellow, and warm brown. The night sky is not simply black and is rarely blue when the moon is absent.

We tend to simplify the night sky into a single color, but nature is rarely that easy.

Moonlight, Wolf, c. 1904, Frederic Remington, courtesy Addison Gallery of American Art

Nocturne Green

Jay suggests that the blue-gray color Clark describes in connection with zodiacal light is what we’ve seen in paintings is what Jay coined Nocturne Green.

Zodiacal light is sunlight scattered by dust in the solar system. It can contribute a subtle, pale glow to a dark sky. Our atmosphere also produces light through a phenomenon, called airglow. Solar radiation energizes atmospheric atoms and molecules, which subsequently emit light as they return to lower-energy states.

To learn more, watch this short video about atmospheric airglow from student Michael Prairie

None of this means that there is green in every night, but rather that green is a scientifically-plausible component of the natural nighttime palette. That’s an invitation to observe rather than assume.

Why do our eyes see different colors at night?

Our vision changes as light fades. In daylight, the cone cells in our eyes provide detailed color vision. In very dim conditions, rod cells become increasingly important. Rods are especially sensitive to blue-green wavelengths, but they don’t provide the same color discrimination as cones. This shift helps explain why nighttime color can be difficult to judge.

Clark explores these issues further in his article on color vision at night.

Our eyes are remarkably good at detecting subtle differences in green under appropriate lighting conditions. But we shouldn’t assume that the color we perceive in darkness is necessarily the same color a camera records, or that either color is objectively ‘true’.

Jay described seeing Nocturne Green in clouds illuminated by a nearly full Moon behind a high cloud layer. He also observed a greenish cast in the evening sky while driving through northern California beneath storm clouds.

Those observations are interesting precisely because they didn’t come from photographs. Human vision and photography don’t usually agree, especially under unusual lighting conditions.

Hunting Birds at Night, 1874, Jean-François Millet, courtesy Philadelphia Museum of Art

What does this mean for painting nocturnes?

Don’t automatically paint the night sky black, blue or green. Look for variations in temperature, value, and hue. A sky might shift from a greenish gray near the horizon to a cooler blue-gray overhead. Thin clouds illuminated by the moon may have a different color from the open sky behind them. Airglow, atmospheric scattering, moonlight, and distant artificial lights can all affect what you see.

Dust in the Milky Way can contribute warm tones, and stars and nebulae introduce their own colors. The sky is not a uniform backdrop; it is a collection of different light sources and atmospheric effects.

Learn to see the night sky like a painter

The point isn’t to establish a new rule of night sky color. Instead, question your assumptions. Look carefully at the sky. Compare the color near the horizon with the color overhead. Notice what moonlight does to clouds, buildings, trees, and water. Pay attention to the difference between what you expect to see and what is actually there. Remember that a photograph is just one data point.

If you’d like to put these ideas to work in your own paintings, join me for my upcoming Painting Nocturnes Zoom class. We’ll explore the colors, values, and light effects that make nighttime landscapes convincing. You’ll learn to see beyond black and blue and develop a more thoughtful approach to painting after dark.

There’s still room in this class:

I have one workshop already scheduled for 2027! Reserve your spot:

Can’t commit to a full workshop? Work online at your own pace:

Seven Protocols for Successful Oil Painters

What do I mean by cozy winter painting anyway?

My mittens, oil on linen, private collection.

This, not summer, is my favorite time of year. While I recognize that winter is just around the corner, I love the shorter days, reading by the fire, the smell of woodsmoke, the crackle of autumn leaves and the wind rattling around the eaves.

There’s something about winter that makes me slow down and think differently.

I don’t stop, I just switch gears

That doesn’t mean I stop painting. Quite the opposite. Winter is a wonderful time to work on the things that are difficult to practice when we’re racing the light, fighting the wind or trying to keep our paint from freezing.

So, I’ve put together three new Zoom classes for the winter season. They’re quite different from one another, but all three are about learning to see more clearly and paint more convincingly.

Christmas Eve 2, oil on canvasboard, private collection.

Cozy Winter Painting

This is the class for those quiet winter scenes we all love, indoors or out. That might be a still life or it might be a winter nocturne; the first question you have to answer is what story you want to tell about togetherness, simplicity, safety and comfort.

We’ll look at how to organize values, use color temperature, simplify complicated scenes, and create that feeling of warmth and shelter without being excessively cute.

In other words, cozy is a painting problem. And like every painting problem, it can be solved. For more information or to register, click here.

“Waves of mercy and grace,” 30X40, oil on canvas, available.

Painting Figures in Real Spaces

I love painting people, but I’m not particularly interested in painting figures as isolated objects. People live, work and play in spaces. They stand in doorways, sit at tables, walk through landscapes, wait in train stations, work in kitchens and gather around campfires. The space around a person is part of the story.

In Painting Figures in Real Spaces, we’ll work on putting figures convincingly into their environments. That means proportion, gesture, perspective, values and edges—but also knowing what to leave out.

You don’t need to become a portrait painter to paint people successfully. You need to understand how a person occupies space.

This class is about that relationship between figure and place. For more information or to register, click here.

“Christmas Eve,” oil on canvasboard, 6X8 private collection.

Painting Nocturnes

After a long hiatus, I’m deep into nocturne painting right now. I suspect that is related to the shortening days; we all like to burrow in at night.

Night painting forces us to rethink color and design. The night is not really black; nor are streetlights or headlights really yellow. Windows aren’t little rectangles of brilliant orange unless the house is on fire. Artificial and natural light at night behave differently.

And then there are edges. Some disappear completely into darkness while others become startlingly sharp.

Painting Nocturnes will look at value, color, artificial light, edges and depth, with plenty of practical painting problems to solve. For more information or to register, click here.

What do I mean by cozy winter painting?

These three classes are really three ways of digging into the changing season: painting its intimacy and the people who share it with us.

And that’s what I mean by cozy winter painting: not staying inside and waiting for spring to start painting again, but painting into the next season with renewed energy.

There’s still room in this class:

I have one workshop already scheduled for 2027! Reserve your spot:

Can’t commit to a full workshop? Work online at your own pace:

Seven Protocols for Successful Oil Painters